After reading The Rainbow I may have got a little more excited than I should have to read Women in Love. Women in Love though seems like a lot more philosophical pondering and less story than The Rainbow had. Ursula almost seems to all have but forgotten the past rocky loves she had, and Gundrun is her sister that is more expanded on in this novel. What keeps the novel a bit more interesting is the two men they fall for, who seem to have a bit of a crush on each other. I would have appropriately retitled this one Men In love.
Summary: Gundrun is an art teacher, and Ursula is still a school teacher, but the two somehow seem to have also fallen into a higher society at the introduction of Hermoine that is apart from the lifestyle they grew up in Beldover in. The two women meet Rupert and Gerald, who are best friends. Ursula falls for Rupert, and Gundrun falls for Gerald. You can't help to wonder why the artist falls for the industrialist though while the school teacher falls for the more intellectual of the two. The reverses just seem better suited. While the women just want the men to love them, it seems the men seem to debacle with their own feelings toward each other, and their own places in the world and what drives them.
Characters: I think the characters are mainly well developed because we stay inside their heads so much. I think it is more enjoyable when there is dialogue. When the characters are thinking to themselves they sort of lose some sort of personality, but to see them airing their concerns and opinions with those that are other characters gives them a lot more character. I think what is sad though is that by the end of the book though the characters aren't as likable as you left off with them in The Rainbow. Gundrun and Ursula seem like strong women, but their identities are so strongly tied to the men they are seeing they never seem secure on their own. Rupert and Gerald are the most interesting characters, but it's difficult to know how to feel about them when their views seem to conflict so much.
Plot: The plot isn't a heavy existing one. Mostly, this is about the personal identity crisis going on in each of the characters. At times the characters seem okay with their life, like Gerald owning the mines, and then when reality sets in then their lives seem to be reevaluated. It's also said that Lawerence vaguely based the book upon his own marriage as well. Much of the parts featuring the Gerald and Rupert's interest in one another was cut from his final draft, but honestly is some of the more interesting bits of the book. They seem to be the more developed characters of the novel, while Ursula has been shelved almost from the character she was.
Writing: The writing style also doesn't flow quite like his other work either. The dialogue is the best part, but the narrative is very difficult to get through. It just feels like you are struggling through what seems rambling and long descriptions of the location they are in. For example when the crew is snowed in to an area they are vacationing in it seems the book drudges on a bit.
Women In Love has some good bits that I'll never forget, but there is something lacking that made the story so good in The Rainbow. Somehow the women even lose that fire that really made them stand out, and it almost seems like they took a back seat to the other men in the novel, which probably could have been better directed in the title.
Rating 6 of 10.

No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.